The Nissan Pathfinder and Toyota Highlander are two of the most popular mid-size SUVs in the market, each catering to families and outdoor enthusiasts with their blend of capability, comfort, and technology. While both vehicles excel in their own right, key differences in design, performance, and features set them apart. Here’s a detailed breakdown to help you decide which SUV suits your needs best.
Design & Aesthetics
The Pathfinder and Highlander sport distinct design philosophies. The Pathfinder leans into a rugged, outdoors-ready aesthetic with bold lines, aggressive styling, and a more utilitarian silhouette. Its latest redesign enhances this “adventure-ready” appeal with a boxy stance and dramatic headlights. In contrast, the Highlander offers a sleeker, more refined look, with smoother curves and a polished finish that emphasizes sophistication. While both prioritize practicality, the Pathfinder’s design may appeal to those wanting a vehicle that looks at home off-road and on-road, while the Highlander attracts buyers seeking a luxurious, polished appearance.
Performance & Engine Options
Under the hood, both SUVs offer capable powerplant choices. The base Pathfinder comes with a 3.5-liter V6 engine producing 280 horsepower and 250 lb-ft of torque, with a smoothly tuned 9-speed automatic transmission. Top-tier trims may opt for a slightly uprated 3.5L V6, while the Highlander also offers a hybrid option (3.5L V6 + electric motor) for eco-conscious drivers, delivering 401 combined horsepower and impressive fuel efficiency. The Pathfinder’s gasoline-only engine gives it an edge in towing capacity (up to 6,400 lbs vs. the Highlander’s 5,000 lbs), making it a better choice for heavy hauling.
Interior Space & Comfort
Both SUVs provide ample cabin space for families, but they differ in layout. The Pathfinder prioritizes cargo versatility, with behind-the-seat storage and fold-flat rear seats that expand its 91.2 cubic feet of cargo volume. The Highlander offers a smoother ride and slightly more front-seat legroom, thanks to its bulkier body. However, the Pathfinder edges out the Highlander in third-row legroom and headroom, crucial for taller passengers. Interior materials in both are high-quality, but Toyota’s refinements give the Highlander a more premium feel.
Technology & Infotainment
Toyota’s Highlander excels with its intuitive infotainment system, featuring a user-friendly touchscreen, Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and premium audio options across trims. The Pathfinder’s system, while functional, is less polished but still offers wireless connectivity and advanced driver-assistance features. Both models include driver-assist tech like lane departure warning, adaptive cruise control, and automatic emergency braking. However, Toyota’s Safety Sense suite is more comprehensive, offering features like pre-collision braking and pedestrian detection standard across trims.
Safety & Reliability
Safety is a strength for both, but Toyota’s long-standing reputation for reliability gives the Highlander an edge. The Pathfinder has earned good safety ratings, but the Highlander boasts a 5-star NHTSA score and consistently ranks among the safest midsize SUVs. Toyota’s hybrid option also provides peace of mind, combining eco-friendliness with fuel economy of up to 36 mpg city/34 mpg highway.
Price & Value
The Pathfinder starts at around $30,000, undercutting the Highlander’s base price of $34,500. However, Toyota’s hybrid option and luxury trims add to its cost, potentially making the Highlander more expensive in higher trims. That said, the Pathfinder’s Maxima trim ($46,000) can rival the Highlander’s top model, offering robust features at a competitive price.
Choosing between the Nissan Pathfinder and Toyota Highlander hinges on priorities. The Pathfinder shines with its rugged design, higher towing capacity, and affordability, making it ideal for adventurers and haulers. The Highlander excels in reliability, hybrid efficiency, and polished refinement, suiting families seeking comfort and long-term value. Both SUVs deliver strong performance and spacious interiors, but the Highlander’s hybrid edge and superior safety features may appeal to eco-conscious buyers, while the Pathfinder’s bold styling and towing prowess cater to outdoor enthusiasts. Ultimately, both are outstanding choices in the crowded midsize SUV market.
